🧪 A Parent’s Guide to the Facts and Myths About Chemicals in Food
By Dr. Pete, Emergency Physician, Professor, and Relentlessly Practical Dad
At a recent birthday party, a fellow parent handed me a gluten-free, dye-free, preservative-free, joy-free cookie and proudly said, “Don’t worry—it’s chemical-free!”
I’ve learned to smile, nod, and then go home and scream into a bag of Cheetos (yes, the orange kind with FD&C Yellow No. 6).
As a physician and a parent, I get it. You want to feed your kids safely. You hear chemical and think of hazmat suits and ominous Netflix documentaries. But here’s the spoiler: all food is chemicals. If it has atoms, it’s a chemical. That includes your kids, by the way.
Let’s break this down. Because the word “chemical” doesn’t mean “toxic,” and natural isn’t always synonymous with “safe.” Arsenic, after all, is natural. So are rattlesnakes.
Let’s unpack this scientifically—but with enough dry humor to make it digestible—because not all additives are bad, and not all “natural” ingredients are good. The word “chemical” doesn’t mean “toxic,” and natural isn’t always synonymous with “safe.” Arsenic, after all, is natural. So are rattlesnakes.
🌎 What Exactly Is a Chemical?
A chemical is any substance with a defined composition. That includes dihydrogen monoxide (water), sodium chloride (salt), and ascorbic acid (vitamin C). “Chemical-free food” is a marketing fantasy. Even an organic apple contains hundreds of naturally occurring compounds—like amygdalin, pectin, and fructose—many with names that sound like ingredients in a NASA rocket booster.
Key truth: “Natural” ≠ safe. “Synthetic” ≠ dangerous. What matters is the dose, the context, and the evidence.
🍭 Popular Food Additives: What the Science Actually Says
1. Monosodium Glutamate (MSG)
Claim: Causes headaches, brain fog, spontaneous combustion.
Reality: MSG is the sodium salt of glutamic acid, found naturally in tomatoes, parmesan, and mushrooms. It adds the savory “umami” flavor.
Science:
Most people show no reaction, even in high-dose, placebo-controlled studies (Geha et al., J Allergy Clin Immunol, 2000).
FDA, WHO, and EFSA all recognize MSG as safe.
A tiny subset of individuals may be sensitive—but symptoms are rare, mild, and short-lived.
Verdict: Safe in moderation. Blaming MSG for your sushi coma? Try hydration.
2. Sodium Nitrite (Cured Meats, Bacon, Hot Dogs)
Claim: Causes cancer and should be avoided entirely.
Reality: Nitrites prevent botulism and preserve color/flavor in meats. The concern is that high-heat cooking can convert nitrites into nitrosamines, which have shown carcinogenic effects in animals.
Science:
WHO’s IARC classifies processed meat as a Group 1 carcinogen, meaning there's sufficient evidence of cancer risk in humans.
The risk: ~18% increased relative risk of colorectal cancer per 50g of processed meat consumed daily (Bouvard et al., Lancet Oncol, 2015).
👉 50g = ~4 slices of bacon, 2 sausage links, or 2–3 slices of deli ham.
❓What About “Uncured” Meats?
Many labels boast “no added nitrites” or “uncured”—but this is largely marketing.
“Uncured” meats use natural nitrite sources (e.g., celery powder), which still form nitrosamines under heat.
Your body doesn’t care if the nitrite came from celery or a lab.
Some “uncured” meats may actually contain more nitrites than traditionally cured ones (Sebranek & Bacus, Meat Sci, 2007).
Bottom line: “Uncured” ≠ nitrite-free or risk-free. The risk relates to processed meat overall, not the label.
✅ Practical Takeaways:
Occasional cured or “uncured” meats are not a major health risk.
For daily lunchbox fillers, opt for roasted chicken, tuna, eggs, or legumes.
And maybe don’t fry your bacon until it resembles obsidian.
3. Artificial Dyes (Red 40, Yellow 5, etc.)
Claim: Cause hyperactivity and ADHD.
Reality: The link isn’t universal—but it's real for some children.
Science:
The 2007 Southampton study raised concern, but had flaws.
A 2021 report from California’s OEHHA found that synthetic dyes can cause neurobehavioral issues in susceptible children.
The FDA considers current levels safe, but acknowledges individual sensitivity. Europe requires warning labels.
Verdict: Reducing dyes makes sense if your child shows sensitivity. But don’t expect dye-free snacks to cure tantrums.
4. High-Fructose Corn Syrup (HFCS)
Claim: Worse than regular sugar.
Reality: HFCS (55% fructose) is nearly identical to sucrose (50% fructose).
Science:
The real issue is excessive intake of all added sugars (White, Am J Clin Nutr, 2008).
A 2023 BMJ umbrella review linked added sugars to 45 negative health outcomes, including diabetes and cardiovascular disease (Huang et al., BMJ, 2023).
Verdict: Don’t obsess over HFCS vs. cane sugar. Cut back on all added sugars.
5. BHA and BHT (Preservatives in Chips & Cereal)
Claim: Cause cancer in animals.
Reality: These antioxidants prevent fats from spoiling.
Science:
Rodent studies used megadoses far beyond human exposure.
Both the FDA and EFSA reviewed the data and consider current food levels safe (EFSA 2011 & 2012).
Verdict: The real risk is a diet dominated by ultra-processed foods—not a trace of BHT in your Cheerios.
🌿 “Natural” Doesn’t Always Mean Safe
Solanine in green potatoes → can cause nausea and neurotoxicity.
Aflatoxins in moldy grains/nuts → linked to liver cancer.
Cyanide in apple seeds → harmless unless you make a smoothie out of 200 cores.
Verdict: “Natural” can be nurturing… or neurotoxic. It depends on the dose.
👶 Should You Be Worried?
Worried? No.
Informed? Absolutely.
📌 Focus on the big-picture habits:
Prioritize whole and minimally processed foods.
Read labels, especially for added sugars and sodium.
Understand that dose matters.
Follow the scientific consensus, not TikTok pseudoscience.
You don’t need a PhD or a Himalayan salt lamp to parent well. You just need balance, evidence, and a sense of humor—especially when your kid tries to classify gummy bears as fruit.
📚 References
Bouvard V, et al. Lancet Oncol. 2015;16(16):1599–1600.
EFSA Journal. 2011;9(12):2471 & 2012;10(3):2588.
Geha RS, et al. J Allergy Clin Immunol. 2000;106(5):973–980.
Huang Y, et al. BMJ. 2023;381:e071609.
OEHHA. “Evidence on the Health Effects of Synthetic Food Dyes.” 2021.
Sebranek JG, Bacus JN. Meat Sci. 2007;77(2):136–147.
White JS. Am J Clin Nutr. 2008;88(6):1716S–1721S.
🧬 ParentRounds Glossary of Terms
Carcinogen: A substance shown to increase cancer risk in humans or animals.
Meta-analysis: A study that pools data from multiple trials to find overall trends.
Group 1 Carcinogen (IARC): Substance with sufficient human evidence of causing cancer.
GRAS: “Generally Recognized as Safe” — FDA’s safety label for common food additives.
Dose-response: More exposure = higher risk. Less exposure = often no effect.
Nitrosamines: Carcinogens that may form when nitrites are exposed to high heat.
Ultra-processed foods: Foods made mostly of additives and industrial ingredients with little or no real food content.
Thanks for reading ParentRounds! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.
Author’s Note on Content Creation
I use AI tools like ChatGPT and Gemini in an iterative workflow to help with reference cross-checking, fact validation, and initial drafts. The final tone, structure, humor, and all opinions remain my own as an emergency physician, educator, and parent. These articles reflect my writing, my judgment, and my voice—with a little help from the robots.